About Us

group_hands420x315First State Insurance Agency was established in 1962 in Middlebury, Indiana. As a wholly owned subsidiary of First State Bank of Middlebury, we have built our agency on the ‘hometown value’ belief.

Our staff has over 100 years of combined experience and will provide you with the knowledge and skill you deserve. Through our partnership with several top-rated carriers, we are able to offer you competitive coverage and rates. We can provide home, auto, and umbrella insurance as well as other coverage for your personal insurance needs. We also can provide solutions for your business insurance concerns. Life insurance, annuities, disability income and health insurance are also available from our seasoned staff.

Call or stop by to meet one of our agents to discuss how we can help you with your personal or business insurance needs.